Gold and silver are often mentioned in the same breath, and they usually move in the same direction. But anyone who has watched them closely will notice that silver’s swings are much bigger. When precious metals rise, silver tends to rise further. When they fall, it tends to fall harder. There are several reasons why.

A much smaller market

The silver market is far smaller than the gold market in value terms. That means a given amount of money flowing in or out has a bigger effect on the price. When large investors pile into precious metals, silver can rocket. When they head for the exit, it can drop sharply, because there are fewer buyers to absorb the selling.

An industrial metal as well as a precious one

Gold is mostly held as jewellery, by central banks and by investors. Silver has a far bigger industrial role. It is used in electronics, solar panels, batteries and medical equipment, and that industrial demand makes up a large share of total use.

That gives silver a split personality. It responds to the same things as gold, such as interest rates and the dollar, but also to the outlook for manufacturing and economic growth. When markets fear a slowdown, silver can be hit twice: once as a precious metal being sold for cash, and again as an industrial metal facing weaker demand. Our guide to silver for beginners covers its uses in more detail.

Speculation and leverage

Silver is popular with speculative traders, partly because its price per ounce is much lower than gold’s, making it feel more accessible. Many of these traders use leverage through futures or other products. When the price moves against them, they may be forced to sell, which pushes the price down further. The reverse happens in a squeeze. These waves of forced buying and selling amplify silver’s moves.

The gold-silver ratio

Traders often track the relationship between the two metals using the gold-silver ratio, which measures how many ounces of silver it takes to buy one ounce of gold. When the ratio rises, gold is outperforming. When it falls, silver is doing better. Because silver tends to overshoot in both directions, the ratio can swing widely during big moves in precious metals.

What this means in a sell-off

In a broad market sell-off, silver often suffers more than gold. Investors raising cash sell both, but silver’s smaller market, its industrial exposure and its leveraged traders all add to the pressure. Our explainer on why gold can fall in a stock market sell-off covers the dash for cash that often drives the first wave of selling.

The reverse is also true. When confidence returns and precious metals recover, silver often bounces harder than gold.

How traders handle it

Because silver is more volatile, traders who switch between the two metals usually take smaller positions in silver for the same level of risk. A move that would be large for gold may be routine for silver. Treating the two as interchangeable is a common mistake, and one that can lead to much bigger losses than expected.

The beginner takeaway

Silver is gold’s wilder cousin. It follows the same broad forces but with bigger swings, thanks to its smaller market, its industrial uses and its popularity with leveraged traders. If you trade it, respect that extra volatility and size your positions accordingly.

Matching your position size to an asset’s volatility is a core part of risk management. If you want an honest view of where your own trading stands, take our free Trader Assessment and see where your strengths and gaps really are.

Sign up to Our Mailing List

Join our mailing list to gain access to the latest news & research.

    Samuel & Co. In The News