There is an old trading saying: never try to catch a falling knife. It describes buying a share or market that is dropping fast, on the assumption that it must have fallen far enough. It is one of the most common mistakes beginners make, and one of the most expensive.

Why it is so tempting

When a share you know well falls sharply, it can look like a bargain. The company is the same as it was last week, so why should it be worth so much less? Buying feels sensible, even brave. And sometimes it works, which reinforces the habit.

The problem is that a fast-falling price usually reflects something real, whether that is bad news, a change in how investors value the whole sector, or forced selling that has not yet run its course. Until that pressure eases, the price can keep falling much further than seems reasonable.

Cheap can always get cheaper

A share that has fallen 30% can fall another 30%. Price alone tells you nothing about whether the selling is over. Many investors who bought early in a sell-off have watched their purchase lose half its value before any recovery began. Our guide to buying every dip in a falling market shows how quickly those losses can build when the trend is firmly down.

The difference between a dip and a downtrend

A dip is a short pullback in a market that is otherwise rising. A downtrend is a series of lower highs and lower lows, where each bounce fails and selling resumes. Buying the dip can work in a healthy uptrend. Buying into a downtrend is catching the knife.

Telling the two apart in real time is not always easy, which is why discipline matters more than prediction.

What experienced traders do instead

Rather than guessing where the bottom is, experienced traders wait for evidence that the selling has eased. That might be the price stabilising and holding a level for several days, a failed attempt to push lower, or a clear change in the news that caused the fall. They accept that they will miss the very lowest price in exchange for a better chance that the worst is over.

Some also scale in, buying a small amount first and adding only if the price confirms their view. And they always decide in advance where they will get out if they are wrong, using a stop-loss.

Watch out for false bounces

Sharp sell-offs often include brief, powerful rallies that fade quickly. Traders call the most extreme version a dead cat bounce. These bounces can draw in buyers who think the bottom has been reached, only for the selling to resume. A single strong day is not proof that a downtrend is over.

Keep position sizes small

If you do decide to buy into weakness, keep the position small. Volatility is usually high during a sell-off, so prices can swing a long way in a short time. A small position gives you room to be wrong without doing serious damage to your account.

The beginner takeaway

A falling share is not automatically a bargain. Before buying into a sharp decline, wait for signs that the selling is easing, decide where you will exit if you are wrong and keep the position modest. Missing the exact bottom is a small price to pay for avoiding a much bigger loss.

Patience and a clear exit plan are what keep beginners out of the worst trades. If you want an honest view of where your own trading stands, take our free Trader Assessment and see where your strengths and gaps really are.

Sign up to Our Mailing List

Join our mailing list to gain access to the latest news & research.

    Samuel & Co. In The News