Utility shares have a reputation as the safe, boring corner of the stock market. They supply electricity, gas and water, demand barely changes from year to year, and they pay steady dividends. So it surprises many beginners when they fall sharply during periods of rising bond yields. There are good reasons for it.

Why utilities behave like bonds

Investors often buy utilities for their income. The dividends are fairly predictable because the businesses are regulated and their customers keep paying bills in good times and bad. That makes utility shares behave a bit like bonds, which also offer steady income.

The comparison works in both directions. When bond yields are low, a utility paying a 5% dividend looks attractive. When gilts start offering similar or higher yields with less risk, some income investors switch, and utility share prices fall until their yields look competitive again. Our beginner guide to utility stocks covers the basics of the sector.

The borrowing cost problem

The second reason is debt. Utilities are heavy borrowers. Building power stations, laying cables, maintaining pipes and upgrading networks costs enormous sums, and they fund much of it with long-term debt.

When interest rates and bond yields rise, the cost of refinancing that debt goes up. Even if a company has fixed-rate borrowing today, it will eventually need to refinance at the new, higher rates. That eats into profits and can limit the money available for dividends or investment. Investors watch measures such as interest cover closely for this reason.

The valuation effect

There is also a more technical reason. Analysts value companies partly by estimating future cash flows and working out what they are worth today. Higher interest rates mean those future cash flows are worth less in today’s money. Because utilities generate steady cash over very long periods, their valuations are quite sensitive to changes in rates.

Why regulation adds a twist

In the UK, water and energy network companies are regulated, with allowed returns set by bodies such as Ofwat and Ofgem. Those allowed returns are often linked to inflation and to the cost of capital, and are reset in periodic reviews. In theory, that can offer some protection when rates and inflation rise.

In practice, there is a lag. A regulator’s view of the cost of capital is fixed for several years at a time, so a sudden jump in yields can squeeze returns until the next review catches up. That timing gap is one reason UK utility shares can underperform during a rate shock even if their long-term position is fine.

When utilities can do well

The relationship works the other way too. When bond yields fall, for example because markets expect interest rate cuts, utilities often rally as their dividends look more attractive again. They can also hold up well when investors are worried about growth, because demand for electricity and water does not collapse in a recession.

The beginner takeaway

“Defensive” does not mean immune. Utilities defend you against economic slowdowns, not against rising interest rates. If you hold them, it is worth watching gilt yields as closely as company news. When the two-year and ten-year gilt yields climb sharply, it is usually a headwind for the sector.

Knowing what really drives the shares you hold, rather than relying on labels like defensive, is a core part of risk management. If you want to see how ready you are to trade with a clear plan, take our free Trader Assessment and find out where your strengths and gaps really are.

Sign up to Our Mailing List

Join our mailing list to gain access to the latest news & research.

    Samuel & Co. In The News